French Onion Beef Stew

It was REALLY hard for me to follow this recipe. I wanted to try it because I always need good slow cooker recipes. It was hard for me to follow because I wanted to change it to fit what I know about cooking. I wanted to brown the beef. I wanted to caramelize the onions. I wanted to use wine instead of apple juice….but I was out of wine. So I followed the recipe. I didn’t do any browning or caramelizing. I just threw it all in the cooker to see what would happen. It didn’t go well…and I ended up having to ad lib. So I started here:

  • 8 sprig(s) fresh thyme,  plus 1 tsp leaves (I didn’t have fresh so I used a tbs of dried Italian seasoning)
  • 1 can(s) low-sodium chicken broth
  • 1 cup(s) apple juice
  • 4 medium carrots,  cut into 1/4-in. pieces
  • 2  onions,  thinly sliced
  • 1.5 pound(s) lean beef stew meat,  trimmed and cut into 1/2-in. pieces
  •  Kosher salt and pepper
  • 3 tablespoon(s) all-purpose flour
  • 4  thick slices country bread
  • 4 ounce(s) Gruyère or Swiss cheese,  grated (about 1 cup)
  1. Tie a piece of thread or kitchen twine around the thyme sprigs and place them in a 5- to 6-qt slow cooker. Add the chicken broth, apple juice, carrots and onions and mix to combine.
  2. Season the beef with 1/2 tsp each salt and pepper; sprinkle with the flour. Add the beef and any excess flour to the slow cooker and mix to combine. Cook, covered, until the beef and vegetables are tender, 7 to 8 hours on low or 4 to 5 hours on high.
  3. When the stew has 10 minutes left to cook, heat the broiler. Place the bread on a foil-lined broiler-proof baking sheet. Sprinkle with the cheese and remaining tsp thyme. Broil until the cheese starts to brown, 1 to 2 minutes. Spoon the stew into bowls and top with the Gruyère toasts.
I tasted it after 6 hours and I didn’t like it. It was ok. It was beef stew. It lacked the French Onion Soup quality I wanted. Excuse me for sounding like a Top Chef judge, but it lacked depth. So I did what any normal (not normal) person would do. I picked through the stew and salvages the broth, beef and carrots. I tosses all the onions. Then I sliced an onion paper thin and put it on the stove…low and slow for about 30 minutes until the onions were brown and gooey and caramelized. Then I added those into the slow cooker. Much better. Next time I would follow my instinct and caramelize the onions and brown the beef before putting them into the slow cooker.
  • http://torriesessions.blogspot.com/ Torrie @ a place to share…

    i’ve had this same thing happen to me far too many times… where i know i should go with my gut, but follow the recipe instead, putting full trust into its creator. so many times that i’ve added the designated amount (i just used the word “designated” in my last comment :) …) of salt instead of following my instinct that it will make it TOO salty. and sure enough, it does. need to remember this next time i’m in that situation. …and i totally know what you mean about beef stew and ‘not enough depth’… one of my biggest issues with slow cooker beef stew recipes.

  • http://torriesessions.blogspot.com/ Torrie @ a place to share…

    next time i will FOR SURE carmelize and brown too!!

  • Josie

    I will eat anything with caramelized onions — no joke. I’m glad that your solution worked out!
    xo Josie
    http://www.winksmilestyle.com

  • Kelly

    Story of my life. I want to follow recipes , but I have so many follow up questions. “Are you sure I shouldn’t brown the beef? Etc. Trust your gut!